Thread:Fossiliferous/@comment-28350189-20160712213334/@comment-24668482-20160714205048

I liked 2 as well, but i think if you had a lot of entries in the list the continuous repetition of the options on the right hand side might be a bit odd looking? So maybe going with your template:

or even:

The implementation may be a little tricky.

The easist way would be wiki article (main space page) like the list of players and list of players gifting/visiting preferences pages. This would allow everyone to edit it themselves to add themselves to the table, but it would not be possible to disable the comments at bottom of page. A link to another place to talk about things might reduce people's usage of the comments. I do not think another article page would work for that, so perhaps linking to the forum - either a dedicated thread or (if going to be a lot of posts) to a board where threads can be made to make it easier to navigate.

Alternatively you could do it as a blog or forum post, either could be closed off to responses, but only you would be able to edit the post (to add people) which might take away from the ease of access thing.

So I would suggest the first option: a page like the other two pages, with a description/instructions text at top that contains link to an area/areas of forum where people could have their discussions.