Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-34343471-20180221224006/@comment-28829111-20180309033708

The Foggy Chest (aka Chest of the Shrouded Ship), The Antique Chest (aka Chest of Antiquities), Chest of the Past, Winter Chest, and Gloomy Chest all have items that can make talismen. If you check the Wiki for the chest descriptions you can see which ones make the Merchant, the Ship, the Gargoyle, the Christmas Star, and the Ghost Buster. As you turn in the sets that make these up they issue varying keys and waffles/cake, too.